A Hollow Victory for Religious Freedom

by | Jul 12, 2021 |

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

You may have heard of the victory Catholic Social Services had against the City of Philadelphia in the Supreme Court. It has been touted as a victory for religious freedom. However, a quick look at the court’s opinion shows that while the court did side with religious freedom, it based this opinion on the flimsiest of standards. While this may be a victory for Catholic Social Services, it is a Trojan horse for religious freedom in America.

What is the role of government in enforcing societal norms? Does the state have the legal power to force compliance with its preferred worldview? A religious freedom case pitting the city of Philadelphia against Catholic Social Services has had its day at the Supreme Court. While the court correctly found for Catholic Social Services, the details prove that judges and lawyers at all levels have a serious comprehension problem when it comes to reading the Constitution of the United States.

For those of you not familiar with the details of Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia, let me quote from the syllabus of the courts opinion:

Philadelphias foster care system relies on cooperation between the City and private foster care agencies. The City enters standard annual contracts with the agencies to place children with foster families. One of the responsibilities of the agencies is certifying prospective foster families under state statutory criteria. Petitioner Catholic Social Services has contracted with the City to provide foster care services for over 50 years, continuing the centuries-old mission of the Catholic Church to serve Philadelphias needy children. CSS holds the religious belief that marriage is a sacred bond between a man and a woman. Because CSS believes that certification of prospective foster families is an endorsement of their relationships, it will not certify unmarried couples—regardless of their sexual orientation—or same-sex married couples. But other private foster agencies in Philadelphia will certify same-sex couples, and no same-sex couple has sought certification from CSS.

WATCH THE VIDEO AND SUBSCRIBE ON RUMBLE

Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia Syllabus

The City of Philadelphia contracts with several agencies to place children with foster families. One of these agencies is Catholic Social Services (referred to as CSS for the remainder of the opinion). What should be a surprise to no one is that CSS, being under the Roman Catholic Church, holds to a Roman Catholic view of marriage and families. For this reason, CSS will not place children with unmarried or same-sex married couples. The court notes that CSS is not the only foster care agency that the City of Philadelphia contracts with, some of who will place children with same-sex couples.

Against this backdrop, a 2018 newspaper story recounted the Archdiocese of Philadelphias position that CSS could not consider prospective foster parents in same-sex marriages. Calls for investigation followed, and the City ultimately informed CSS that unless it agreed to certify same-sex couples, the City would no longer refer children to the agency or enter a full foster care contract with it in the future. The City explained that the refusal of CSS to certify same-sex married couples violated both a non-discrimination provision in the agencys contract with the City as well as the non-discrimination requirements of the citywide Fair Practices Ordinance.

Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia Syllabus

Everything was fine until an article pointed out the Archdiocese of Philadelphia refused to let CSS consider same-sex married couples as potential foster parents. Remember, according to the court, no same-sex couple had even asked CSS to foster a child with them, so no one has been refused anything. However, the article, and subsequent calls for investigation (by whom isnt mentioned) were sufficient for the city to inform CSS that, unless they agreed to place children with same-sex couples, the city would no longer refer children to them. Why did the City of Philadelphia do this? They claimed it violated the non-discrimination provisions of both the contract the city had with CSS and the citys Fair Practices Ordinance.

Catholic Social Services and three affiliated foster parents sued to keep the city from enforcing its decision not to do business with them anymore, claiming it violated the Free Exercise Clause of the Constitution of the United States. The District Court denied CSSs case, and the Third Circuit agreed, claiming both the contractual requirement and the citys ordinance were both neutral and generally applicable. CSS and the foster parents appealed to the Supreme Court, which held:

The refusal of Philadelphia to contract with CSS for the provision of foster care services unless CSS agrees to certify same-sex couples as foster parents violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.

Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia Syllabus

First Amendment

Lets start with the question of the First Amendment. This case cannot be a violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. The First Amendment states:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;

U.S. Constitution, Amendment I

Congress did not create the Fair Practices Ordinance or the contractual requirements for foster care agencies; the City of Philadelphia did. Therefore, these actions are by the city, not Congress, and do not fall under the restrictions of the First Amendment. They do, however, fall under the Constitution of Pennsylvania:

All men have a natural and indefeasible right to worship Almighty God according to the dictates of their own consciences; no man can of right be compelled to attend, erect or support any place of worship, or to maintain any ministry against his consent; no human authority can, in any case whatever, control or interfere with the rights of conscience, and no preference shall ever be given by law to any religious establishments or modes of worship.

The Constitution of Pennsylvania, Article I, §3

Since the Constitution of Pennsylvania prohibits interference with the rights of conscience, the laws of the City of Philadelphia cannot compel CSS to violate theirs. What about those who do not wish to support a ministry of the Roman Catholic Church? Or what about the citizens of Philadelphia who do not wish to support ministries that discriminate against religious teachings? Both questions are moot, since no law can give preference to any religious establishment or mode of worship. Since faithful Roman Catholics believe that marriage is between one man and one woman, and that the best place for children to be raised is with a legally married couple, to deny them the opportunity to exercise their religion by the dictates of their own conscience would be to give preference to those religious establishments that do not hold to the same convictions.

What about the neutral and generally applicable test? This test” comes from an opinion authored by Justice Scalia in the case Employment Division v. Smith (referred to in the opinion simply as Smith.

Although a State would be prohibiting the free exercise [of religion]” in violation of the Clause if it sought to ban the performance of (or abstention from) physical acts solely because of their religious motivation, the Clause does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a law that incidentally forbids (or requires) the performance of an act that his religious belief requires (or forbids) if the law is not specifically directed to religious practice and is otherwise constitutional as applied to those who engage in the specified act for nonreligious reasons.

Employment Division v. Smith

In the Smith case, which involved the denial of unemployment benefits for the use of peyote during religious ceremonies, Justice Scalia admits that the State of Oregon was prohibiting the free exercise of the respondents’ religion, but the justice said that was OK because the law was not specifically directed at their religious practices. Hence the neutral and generally applicable test is unconstitutional because the Constitution says Congress shall make no law,” not shall only make neutral and generally applicable laws related to freedom of religion.” Based on the logic of Justice Scalia, both the state and federal governments can abridge the right to freely exercise their religion as long as they didnt target only religious practices. A flagrant violation not only of the Constitution of the United States, but of Justice Scalias oath of office, this is an excellent example of bad behavior indeed. Since courts today inflate their own opinions above the Constitution theyve sworn or affirmed to support, we see Justice Scalias mistake has expanded and grown to the point that some judges believe churches can be classified as non-essential” and shut down in an emergency.

In the Fulton v. Philadelphia case, the court found that CSSs freedom of religion was abridged.

The Citys actions burdened CSSs religious exercise by forcing it either to curtail its mission or to certify same-sex couples as foster parents in violation of its religious beliefs.

Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia Syllabus

The rest of the syllabus goes on to support their opinion with egregious arguments. Not because the City of Philadelphia violated the Constitution of Pennsylvanias religious freedom clauses, nor because it denied Roman Catholics the equal protection of the law (a violation of the Fourteenth Amendment). No, the only reason Justice Roberts used in the syllabus, and to which all of the other justices agreed in part or in whole, was that the City of Philadelphias contractual requirements were not generally applicable.” How do they find that?

The non-discrimination requirement of the Citys standard foster care contract is not generally applicable. Section 3.21 of the contract requires an agency to provide services defined in the contract to prospective foster parents without regard to their sexual orientation. But section 3.21 also permits exceptions to this requirement at the sole discretion” of the Commissioner. This inclusion of a mechanism for entirely discretionary exceptions renders the non-discrimination provision not generally applicable.

Fulton et al. v. City of Philadelphia Syllabus

Since exceptions to the contract requirements are, according to the court, at the sole discretion of the Commissioner, they are not generally applicable. That means all the City of Philadelphia has to do is remove the exception from the language, and the Supreme Court says they can abridge the free exercise of the CSSs religious beliefs all they want. As for the citys Fair Practices Ordinance, the court said it did not apply because CSS did not meet the definition of a public accommodation” under that law.

So it appears Catholic Social Services of Philadelphia lives to foster another day. However, this victory is not based on the law, but the fickle opinions of a handful of judges. What if another court does not think an exception clause violates general applicability? And what if the City of Philadelphia modifies the exception clause to make it more neutral?

Not only has the court told the City of Philadelphia exactly what they need to do in order to compel CSS to consider same-sex couples for adoption or lose their contract, but they have also pulled the wool over the eyes of the American people. They have claimed that they are upholding the rule of law, while bringing in yet another Trojan Horse full of judges claiming the power to overturn the Constitution based solely on what they think. This may be a victory for Catholic Social Services, but it is a pyrrhic victory for the American people.

Paul Engel

Author and speaker Paul Engel has spent more than 20 years studying and teaching about both the Bible and the U.S. Constitution. That experience helps Paul explain difficult concepts in a way most people can understand. As one manager described, “Paul can take the most complex idea and explain it in a way my grandmother can understand.” Freely admitting that he “learned more about our Constitution from School House Rock (a Saturday morning cartoon) than in 12 years of school,” he says that anyone can be a constitutional scholar. Since 2014 I have been helping everyday Americans read and study the Constitution of their country and teaching the rising generation to be free. Using news and current events as a springboard, I explain the Constitution and encourage others to stand up and secure the blessings of liberty for themselves, their children, and the nation.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Disclaimer: The information contained in this website is for educational, general information, and entertainment purposes only and is never intended to constitute medical or legal advice or to replace the personalized care of a primary care practitioner or legal expert.

While we endeavor to keep this information up to date and correct, the information provided by America Out Loud, its website(s), and any properties (including its radio shows and podcasts) makes no representations, or warranties of any kind, expressed, or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to its website(s) or the information, products, services or related graphics and images contained on the website(s) for any purpose.

The opinions expressed on the website(s), and the opinions expressed on the radio shows and podcasts, are the opinions of the show hosts and do not necessarily represent the opinions, beliefs, or policies of anyone or any entity we may endorse. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.

At no time, nor in any event, will we be liable for any loss, or damage, including without limitation, indirect or consequential loss of data or profits arising out of, in an association of, or connection with the use of this website.

Through this website, users can link to other websites that may be listed. Those websites are not under the control of America Out Loud or its brands. We have no control over the nature, content, or availability of those sites. America Out Loud has no control over what the sites do with the information they collect. The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation, nor does it endorse the views expressed with or by them.

Every effort is made to keep the website up and running smoothly. However, America Out Loud takes no responsibility for, nor are we, and will not be liable for being temporarily unavailable due to technical difficulties beyond our control. America Out Loud does not sell, trade, nor market email addresses or other personal data.

Use the code ‘OUTLOUD’ and receive your 20% discount on your first order.

Obama-Era Iran Appeasement Under Biden Undermines Trump Middle East Peace

Obama-Era Iran Appeasement Under Biden Undermines Trump Middle East Peace

In addition to supporting Palestinian Hamas, Lebanese Hezbollah, and other Middle East terrorist groups, Iran is also known to have been providing financing for North Korea’s nuclear military program in return for missile technology over at least the past two decades. The JCPOA has funded Middle East Mullah proxy exploits, allowed Tehran to continue to enrich uranium while…

The War on Ending Poverty

The War on Ending Poverty

Unfortunately, the welfare programs created under the War on Poverty prevent those on welfare from working: if someone gets a job, their welfare is taken away. Additionally, welfare is only given to single-parent households, which has incentivized fathers to leave the home. For African Americans, this effect has been particularly devastating – before the War on Poverty, less than 30% of African American children were raised in single-parent households, and now more than 70% are…

Hamas – Israel Conflict Explained in One Picture

Hamas – Israel Conflict Explained in One Picture

One thing is a stark reality, Hamas, Hezbollah, and Muslims have mastered the art of propaganda and deception to levels, so far exceeding those of Goebbels and Pravda; they put them to shame. Regrettably, they have achieved this mastery with the complicit and willing help of the Western media. Here is a must-watch video articulating the Hamas-Israel war with a single picture, one that is worth 100,000 words…

Hamas: “Not a Ceasefire, Just a Hudna”

Hamas: “Not a Ceasefire, Just a Hudna”

This war is far from over, and the hudna, now in place, is temporary. Hamas has been given yet another opportunity to “build back better,” and the Biden Administration has promised to help – with billions of dollars of American taxpayer money. This is a story that will continue to repeat itself for decades until the West finally understands that Hamas does not want peace, and will continue to strike, be struck, then rebuild endlessly with other people’s money in order to follow their evil and fruitless dream of…

H.R.1 Election Integrity Act is a Wolf in Wolf’s Clothing

H.R.1 Election Integrity Act is a Wolf in Wolf’s Clothing

The Biden administration makes no secret of its effort to turn America into a one-party state–their party, of course. They apparently envy Russia and China and hope to one day make the U.S. a communist nation where only the richest, most powerful people rule. The money behind the Democrats 2020 electoral success and the fraud they managed to pull off is supported by the same autocrats who now limit your free speech, the people behind Amazon, Facebook, Twitter, the Gates Foundation, and Google…

Biden’s Destructive Policies Are Just Starting

Biden’s Destructive Policies Are Just Starting

Trump had dialogues, and Xi listened. So did Kim Jong-un of North Korea. Now, nobody listens because China has Biden’s number and sees him as incompetent as his policies are driving America into a ditch. Biden is beholden to China. Even Israel’s government won’t listen to Biden’s advice that will surely destroy them. Clearly, that speaks to how other world leaders consider Joe Biden’s leadership…

Is Coca-Cola Destroying the Planet?

Is Coca-Cola Destroying the Planet?

In 2020, the company producing Coca-Cola was hard at work producing CO2 during the pandemic, adding 5.4 MILLION metric tons to our beloved planet’s atmosphere. Just when you thought the damage to the planet from Coca-Cola could not get any worse, the management of the company has worked hard not to let you down. In addition to all that CO2, Coca-Cola is one of the largest users of aluminum cans in the world. 300,000 tons of…

The Infrastructure Bill is the Latest Violation of Federal Dollars Spent Unconstitutionally

The Infrastructure Bill is the Latest Violation of Federal Dollars Spent Unconstitutionally

The spending spree that has marked the beginning of the Biden administration is not a compassionate act; it’s bribery. The American people are selling their birthright to freedom and liberty for a few coins borrowed in our own name. There has been a lot of questions asked about the latest infrastructure bill in Congress. Can we afford it? Where will the money be spent? The one question I have not heard asked? Is it constitutional?

America’s Adversaries Cheer Biden’s Reversals of Trump Foreign Policies

America’s Adversaries Cheer Biden’s Reversals of Trump Foreign Policies

Painfully recall that the impotent 2016 JCPOA agreement didn’t stop Iran’s nuclear weapons advancement, nor even address the development of long-range missiles to launch them our way. This assault on America’s energy self-sufficiency is occurring at a time when Russia is stepping up completion of a Gazprom Nord Stream 2 pipeline that will sell its natural gas to Europe. Both China and Russia have cultivated ties with the Kabul government and the Taliban…

Vaccine Coercion and Impact on Children, Pregnant Women & COVID Survivors

Vaccine Coercion and Impact on Children, Pregnant Women & COVID Survivors

“There is no doubt in my mind that we’re already starting to see steps in that direction, where independent entities will likely be requiring proof of vaccination before you can either get on a plane or step into a university campus,” Fauci explained. Dr. Peter McCullough is joined by Dr. Harvey Risch, Professor of Epidemiology at Yale University, appearing on The Ingraham Angle to tackle recent comments from CDC and Anthony Fauci…

Toxic Family Ties – Is Blood Really Thicker Than Water?

Toxic Family Ties – Is Blood Really Thicker Than Water?

When it comes to mental and emotional health, I applaud anyone who has the courage to speak out. Mental health doesn’t care whether someone has a crown, a throne, a royal lineage, or a multi-million-dollar mansion. In my view, this wasn’t about taking sides. It was about having compassion and empathy for any family going through such a challenging time and – for me, at least – hoping the younger royals might…

Earmarks, Spending, and a Dysfunctional Congress

Earmarks, Spending, and a Dysfunctional Congress

Now, with both Congress and the presidency barely in their hands, and time running short for them, they have enacted a fast run Ponzi scheme using American taxpayer funds creating massive phony spending programs. All under the guise of it being for the family, like payroll protection plans, protecting Americans from the horrors of a Chinese Virus which gave them the excuse to collapse our economy through fear and then entrapped our citizens in the “Tar Baby” goo of…

Your Source for Free Speech, Talk Radio, Podcasts, and News.

 

Here we take on the challenges of our generation so that we can preserve future generations. Please consider making a contribution in the fight for liberty!

Header

“My concern is not whether God is on our side; my greatest concern is to be on God's side, for God is always right.” - Abraham Lincoln

iHeartRadio

The APPS are free; the mission is priceless!

Free APP
Healthycell Telomere

Podcast Networks

Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts
Spotify
Pandora
Tunein
iHeart
Stitcher

Subscribe and Listen on Your Favorite APP

Our Columnists and Show Hosts

Truth For Health

Apple Podcasts

COVID Solution Summit

Apple Podcasts

Evacuating Americans & fully-vetted Afghan's at Risk - Help Us!

Apple Podcasts

Empowering and mentoring conservative trailblazers from Generation Z to win!

Apple Podcasts

Turning Point Action is Recruiting Precinct Chairs - Become a Grassroots Warrior Today!

Apple Podcasts

URGENT - KEEP NINE
Please join us to protect the Supreme Court:
Sign the Petition!

Apple Podcasts

The LATINO USA EXIT from the Democrat Party, click for details...

Apple Podcasts

Fighting corporate censorship and ensuring voter integrity...

Apple Podcasts

Support wounded and fallen police officers. The Wounded Blue.

Wounded Blue
Share via
Copy link