Is Obesity a Disease or a Consequence of a Chosen Lifestyle?

by | Oct 5, 2021 |

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

By Chuck Dinerstein, MD, MBA, Director of Medicine,

There’s no doubt that obesity is a growing global problem. It lies at one end of the spectrum from its less-discussed – but the equally malnourished – polar opposite: hunger. Given that some argue that defining obesity as a disease will change the trajectory of the problem for the better, it’s time for a closer examination.  

What is a disease?

That, of course, is the million-dollar question, and as you have come to learn, it is complicated. We are biological creatures, and to our best understanding, we are in an equilibrium internally and externally. That equipoise, let’s for the minute call it, ease of being, is a dynamic process; we tend to focus on the internal ease of being, but the increasing concern over the socioeconomic determinants of health expresses the ease of being with the external environment. 

If one now takes disease and breaks it in two, dis-ease, then we have an experiential sense of how to define a dis-ease. Again, most internal dis-eases have been given a status as a disease, but in reality, they are a phenotype with many underlying features and causes. Diabetes, the dis-ease of glucose regulation, has Type I and II, and some argue for a pre-diabetic condition. More to the point, obesity encompasses many internal and external dis-eases of being. The internal concerns include diabetes and cardiovascular disease; the external dis-eases including body shaming and a visceral bias against the overweight. Those external dis-eases may well be more cultural than biological, as anyone who has viewed the work of Rubens knows.

In 2013, over the objection of their council of experts, the AMA’s House of Delegates defined obesity as a disease. 

That our AMA: (1) recognize obesity and overweight as a chronic medical condition (de facto disease state) and urgent public health problem; (2) recommend that providers receive appropriate financial support and payment from third-party payers, thus ensuring that providers have an incentive to manage the complex diseases associated with obesity; (3) work with third-party payers and governmental agencies to recognize obesity intervention as an essential medical service; and (4) establish a comprehensive ICD code for medical services to manage and treat obese and overweight patients.” [emphasis added]

I added the emphasis because all three of these points address payment for treatment, whether WW (the old Weight Watchers), medications, or our current most favored, bariatric surgery. For the cynical amongst us, this might be considered self-serving on the part of physicians.

Report Of The Council On Science And Public Health

A re-reading of the report of those AMA experts demonstrates how little has changed now that obesity is a treatable condition. While we might argue that we can identify obesity when we see it, that is insufficient for those footing the bills – they want quantifiable, objective criteria. The most ubiquitous is the BMI or body mass index. It is a cheap, easily applied (involving only weight and height) screening tool, but as the report notes, 

Associations between BMI and adiposity (as well as disease risk, described below) vary by age, gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, stature, and athletic training. These variations generally reflect population-specific differences in body composition, fat distribution, causes of overweight, and genetic susceptibility. As a screening tool for obesity, BMI demonstrates low sensitivity, particularly at BMIs below 30.”

The gist – BMI is much better at identifying the non-obese. Of course, those standardized cutoff values are subject to revision, just as we continue to lower the criteria for being hypertensive. 

The Council found designating obesity as a disease would bring greater investments by government and the private sector to develop and reimburse obesity treatments.” That includes medications, surgery, and obesity prevention programs. It might also mean that discrimination based on body weight might be illegal. But more importantly, obesity as a disease would shift societal perceptions. 

Lack of self-control, laziness, and other detrimental character attributes might be less likely to be associated with obese individuals, and in turn reduce stigmatization.”

On the other hand, obesity as a disease would medicalize” obesity making the pill or knife the more relied upon alternatives.

Public perceptions may shift due to more extensive recognition of obesity as a disease, with a greater appreciation of, and emphasis on, the complex etiology of obesity and the health benefits of achieving and maintaining a healthy weight. Moreover, as BMI became a vital sign, as did pain (which ushered in the era of opioid diversion), the environment might shift away from healthy eating and physical activity.” Finally, obesity as a disease would result in higher insurance costs. 

Does Obesity Lie Within Our Control?

This is really the concern underlying obesity as a disease. 

“Obesity is a disorder which, like venereal disease, is blamed upon the patient. The finding that treatment doesn’t work is ascribed to lack of fortitude.” Edwin Astwood, MD

The suggestion that obesity is not a disease but rather a consequence of a chosen lifestyle exemplified by overeating and/or inactivity is equivalent to suggesting that lung cancer is not a disease because it was brought about by individual choice to smoke cigarettes.” AMA Resolution

It is tough to think of a way to more dramatically stigmatize an individual than to call them a smoker! Fat and body shaming are culture memes and are stand-ins for lack of control or willpower. The obese remain victims, but now it is less a societal, cultural victimization; they, after all, have a disease. And we don’t shame those with illnesses, do we? To the advocates of obesity as a disease, fat-shaming, and employer bias all contribute to the increased stress that in turn promotes stress-eating and hesitancy of pursuing exercise in public venues, like gyms. 

We do gain weight as we age, roughly 2 pounds annually, in our middle years. And during or after weight loss there is a disproportionate increase in the drive to eat and decrease in energy expenditure creating “the perfect storm” for weight regain” – there is biology at work here.  

Obesity, as with many problems, lies within and outside of our control simultaneously. It might be better to think of obesity due to our underlying genetics, our metabolic condition, and our lifestyle choices. The relative contribution of each will vary with the individual. I have made some poor lifestyle choices at times, and they have been reflected in my weight. I am trying to make better choices, but that is tough but far easier than another pill, let alone an operation. For the morbidly obese, their metabolic and biological changes are almost insurmountable; a knife or medication can restore a balance between their choices and underlying physiology. 

The Council report to the AMA ends on this note. Thus, rather than trying to determine if obesity meets arguably arbitrary disease criteria, the more relevant question is would health outcomes be improved if obesity is considered a chronic, medical disease state?”

To the extent that payment for treatment might improve outcomes, the answer is yes. If the goal is now to reduce stigma, then shifting victimization from cultural norms to the fault of our cells” is not a solution. 

Dr. Charles Dinerstein, M.D., MBA, FACS, is Director of Medicine at the American Council on Science and Health. He has over 25 years of experience as a vascular surgeon.

Sources: “Obesity Is a Disease, Recognize It as Such” Medpage
A.M.A. Recognizes Obesity as a Disease NY Times
AMA’s Report of the Council on Science and Public Health, Is Obesity a Disease

Dr. Charles Dinerstein will appear on The Other Side of the Story this Saturday, Oct 9th, and Sunday, Oct 10th at 11 AM ET, with an encore at 8 PM. Listen on iHeart Radio, our world-class media player, or our free apps on AppleAndroid, or Alexa. Each episode goes to major podcast networks early in the week and can be heard on-demand anywhere in the world.

Use the code ‘OUTLOUD’ and save 15%
Notify of
1 Comment
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
H Parsons
H Parsons
7 months ago

Fat Man

Don’t want to be a fat man
People would think that I was just good fun
Would rather be a thin man
I am so glad to go on being one

Too much to carry around with you
No chance of finding a woman, who
Will love you in the morning and all the nighttime too

Don’t want to be a fat man
Have not the patience to ignore all that
Hate to admit to myself
I thought my problems came from being fat

Won’t waste my time feeling sorry for him
I’ve seen the other side to being thin
Roll us both down a mountain and I’m sure the fat man would win

Songwriter: Ian Anderson

Fat Man lyrics © The Ian Anderson Group Of Companies Ltd, Anderson Ian Music Ltd

Disclaimer: The information contained in this website is for educational, general information, and entertainment purposes only and is never intended to constitute medical or legal advice or to replace the personalized care of a primary care practitioner or legal expert.

While we endeavor to keep this information up to date and correct, the information provided by America Out Loud, its website(s), and any properties (including its radio shows and podcasts) makes no representations, or warranties of any kind, expressed, or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to its website(s) or the information, products, services or related graphics and images contained on the website(s) for any purpose.

The opinions expressed on the website(s), and the opinions expressed on the radio shows and podcasts, are the opinions of the show hosts and do not necessarily represent the opinions, beliefs, or policies of anyone or any entity we may endorse. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.

At no time, nor in any event, will we be liable for any loss, or damage, including without limitation, indirect or consequential loss of data or profits arising out of, in an association of, or connection with the use of this website.

Through this website, users can link to other websites that may be listed. Those websites are not under the control of America Out Loud or its brands. We have no control over the nature, content, or availability of those sites. America Out Loud has no control over what the sites do with the information they collect. The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation, nor does it endorse the views expressed with or by them.

Every effort is made to keep the website up and running smoothly. However, America Out Loud takes no responsibility for, nor are we, and will not be liable for being temporarily unavailable due to technical difficulties beyond our control. America Out Loud does not sell, trade, nor market email addresses or other personal data.

Exposing Russia as a Military Fraud, Is China Next?

Exposing Russia as a Military Fraud, Is China Next?

If we had looked closely in those intervening years, we could have seen the clues of their demise. Many in my field (CE/CI) did, but the world had changed. Politicians facing the prospective loss of political control through fear-mongering of something ⏤ Russia then and China now ⏤ limited any real responses that could have achieved a safe world with Russia in it…

Take a Look at the Positive Side of Anarchy

Take a Look at the Positive Side of Anarchy

The only way to achieve liberty and peace is to restore law and order. And the only way to restore law and order is to literally crush the forces of evil. When that begins to happen, we do actually see the positive side of tyranny and anarchy. Conflict is a bedfellow of oppression. Therefore we must end the conflict and, in doing so, end the tyranny. Here’s the positive side of this war…

It’s a LONG-HAUL with COVID-19

It’s a LONG-HAUL with COVID-19

The context is that about 50% of those hospitalized with COVID-19 develop post-COVID symptoms. Severe outpatients also are affected. Characteristic symptoms include headache, hearing loss, tinnitus, loss of olfactory function, sleep disturbance, muscle aches, weakness, fatigue, and chest or abdominal pain…

Be the One.

Be the One.

Be the one — no longer willing to huddle together in the helpless band — the one who dares to join the fight. Another will follow you and then another, and in a flash of time, that bleeding hulk of our nation — once the great light of liberty to the world, now barely flickering — will rise again to throw off the wolves like it has done before, sending them scurrying for safety…

Major Medical Mystery: Why Some People Despite Exposure Don’t Get COVID

Major Medical Mystery: Why Some People Despite Exposure Don’t Get COVID

A small fraction of Americans have escaped COVID infection. CDC uses a figure of 60% for those infected, while the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington says that 76% have been infected. The remainder may have escaped exposure or been exposed but escaped infection. The latter people are the subject of the medical mystery…

Correcting America’s Course Back to the Constitutional Rule of Law

Correcting America’s Course Back to the Constitutional Rule of Law

The US Constitution must scrupulously be followed, especially by the judiciary. It is not for judges to make laws; it is for them to observe and rule on the constitutionality of issues before them. Their oaths, taken upon their confirmations, should include the understanding that their failures to follow judicial protocols would end in their termination…

Does Joe Biden Aspire to be America’s Last President?

Does Joe Biden Aspire to be America’s Last President?

Most ominously, no American administration has ever seemed so entirely unconcerned about hemorrhaging political capital. And that lack of concern about voters’ approval can only mean that this administration no longer believes it relies on political capital (the consent of the governed) for power. We can only assume that this Marxist-aligned administration intends to authorize itself with whatever power it requires to achieve its ends…

America Out Loud 6 years

Celebrating 6 incredible years fighting to restore liberty and justice to our beloved America.

Your Source for Free Speech, Talk Radio, Podcasts, and News.


Here we take on the challenges of our generation so that we can preserve future generations. Please consider making a contribution in the fight for liberty!


The APPS are free; the mission is priceless!

Free APP

Podcast Networks

Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts

Subscribe and Listen on Your Favorite APP

Our Columnists and Show Hosts

Truth For Health

Apple Podcasts

COVID Solution Summit

Apple Podcasts

Evacuating Americans & fully-vetted Afghan's at Risk - Help Us!

Apple Podcasts

Empowering and mentoring conservative trailblazers from Generation Z to win!

Apple Podcasts

Turning Point Action is Recruiting Precinct Chairs - Become a Grassroots Warrior Today!

Apple Podcasts

Please join us to protect the Supreme Court:
Sign the Petition!

Apple Podcasts

The LATINO USA EXIT from the Democrat Party, click for details...

Apple Podcasts

Fighting corporate censorship and ensuring voter integrity...

Apple Podcasts

Support wounded and fallen police officers. The Wounded Blue.

Wounded Blue
Share via
Copy link